- NASCAR DFS: Monkey Knife Fight Picks for the Ally 400
- PGA DFS and Monkey Knife Fight Picks: US Open
- Key Analysis of FFPC ADPs Part 1
- Monkey Knife Fights Picks and Preview: NASCAR All-Star Race
- PGA DFS Palmetto Championship Preview
- Monkey Knife Fight: The Best DFS Site You’re Not Using
- Best Ball Analysis Part 2: 20 Round View
- “The Instant Rebuild” Dynasty Team: Year 2
- PGA DFS Memorial Tournament Preview
- PGA DFS Charles Schwab Challenge Preview
Fantasy Baseball: Closing Arguments – Add Corey Knebel
-
Updated: May 22, 2017

Welcome to this week’s installment of closing arguments where I help you find some closers to add to your fantasy baseball squad. I suggest you roster Corey Knebel where you can folks. The majors saw a lot of turnover recently in the closing ranks. Depending on your league type, some of these players may be available. By the way, is anyone else wondering when the show Fargo will tie back into the season’s opening scene? Well, let’s dive into some research to distract ourselves.
| Current Closer | Next in line | Team | League | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brad Brach | Darren O'Day | Baltimore | American League | Zach Britton DL |
| Craig Kimbrel | Joe Kelly | Boston | American League | |
| Dellin Betances | Adam Warren | New York Yankees | American League | Aroldis Chapman DL |
| Alex Colome | Brad Boxberger | Tampa Bay | American League | |
| Roberto Osuna | Jason Grilli | Toronto | American League | |
| David Robertson | Tommy Kahnle | Chicago White Sox | American League | Nate Jones DL |
| Cody Allen | Andrew Miller | Cleveland | American League | |
| Justin Wilson | Francisco Rodriguez | Detroit | American League | |
| Kelvin Herrera | Joakim Soria | Kansas City | American League | |
| Brandon Kintzler | Ryan Pressly | Minnesota | American League | |
| Ken Giles | Luke Gregerson | Houston | American League | |
| Bud Norris | Yusmeiro Petit | Los Angeles Angeles | American League | |
| Santiago Casilla | Ryan Madson | Oakland | American League | |
| Edwin Diaz | Nick Vincent | Seattle | American League | |
| Matt Bush | Jeremy Jeffress | Texas | American League | |
| Jim Johnson | Mauricio Cabrera | Atlanta | National League | |
| A.J. Ramos | Kyle Barraclough | Miami | National League | |
| Addison Reed | Fernando Salas | New York Mets | National League | Jeurys Familia - Blood clot issue |
| Hector Neris | Joaquin Benoit | Philadelphia | National League | |
| Shawn Kelley | Blake Treinen | Washington | National League | Koda Glover DL |
| Wade Davis | Carl Edwards | Chicago Cubs | National League | |
| Raisel Iglesias | Drew Storen | Cincinnati | National League | |
| Corey Knebel | Jacob Barnes | Milwaukee | National League | |
| Tony Watson | Daniel Hudson | Pittsburgh | National League | |
| Seung Hwan Oh | Trevor Rosenthal | St. Louis | National League | |
| Fernando Rodney | Randall Delgado | Arizona | National League | |
| Greg Holland | Adam Ottavino | Colorado | National League | |
| Kenley Jansen | Sergio Romo | Los Angeles Dodgers | National League | |
| Brandon Maurer | Ryan Buchter | San Diego | National League | |
| Mark Melancon | Derek Law | San Francisco | National League |
Fake Pigskin Exclusive: Join Monkey Knife Fight and Get an Instant 100% Deposit Match PLUS a Free $5 Game!
It is highly unlikely you can add Betances or Melancon who have regained their closer roles. Depending on your league Addison Reed, may be available. He is the best player to add, based on performance, job security, and save opportunities. I won’t dwell on him because he is probably not available. Just for an idea of my rankings, I dropped Bud Norris for Reed in two leagues. The Angels closer situation is best left to someone else in your league.
Santiago Casilla is the safest pick of the remaining names. He is also the least exciting. Oakland is a lousy team and Casilla has been mediocre in the past year or two.
Shawn Kelley is the most available for good reason. The Nationals have all but posted a billboard on I-95 saying they are trying to trade for closer. Dusty Baker has been rotating all season between Kelley, Blake Treinen, and Koda Glover. I would avoid this whole situation unless you are desperate for saves.
Corey Knebel is still available in 35% of leagues and that number should be higher. He has the stuff to hold down the gig. The Brewers are not the Cubs, but they have been holding their own. Knebel is my recommended add because of his availability and his stuff. However, he could lose the back to Neftali Feliz. It is also likely one or both of them gets traded near July 31st.
Fangraphs shows Corey Knebel has already been worth 1.1 wins above replacement (WAR). On their website you can learn more about this metric, should you choose. The main reason I bring this up, is that this is a very high number only 25% of the way through the season. It would mean he is on pace to add over FOUR wins to the Brewers projected total, solely based on his performance. That is amazing. Even if the save opportunities become less frequent, Corey Knebel’s stuff will help you with strikeouts, and your ERA/WHIP ratios. This is why I recommend adding him where you can.



