Third Base Rankings: Roto

When I ranked my second baseman I thought it couldn’t get any more ugly than that, but third base may have proven me wrong! We have the top end guys spanning the elite and the guys who easily could make that step, and then we hit a tricky tier where you’re balancing production with enough to risk to make me feel they are overvalued entering 2015.

I have the Adrian Beltre/Evan Longoria group in the five/six hole, but with their current ADP’s I can’t fathom me owning either of them, especially with the huge group of strong options that don’t have the same upside maybe but come at a much better cost. Where this group gets really messy is when you move out of the top 15 and there is just such limited upside (Semien and Bogaerts will be fine at 2B/SS but aren’t good enough for this position). The upside lies in the Cody Asche/Maikel Franco/Miguel Sano group who aren’t going to get enough playing time to move up a tier, but they have the talent to be decent options. Even Luis Valbuena could move up to top 25 if he wasn’t a platoon player.

As a quick reminder about using the tiers/rankings below:

  • I rank based on where I for see a player finishing the year
  • I don’t overly consider ADP into account when I rank
  • Just because Player 1 is ranked above Player 2 does not mean that I think he should be selected before him if you can get Player 1 five rounds late
  • I may consider taking Player 1 a round earlier than he is currently going to ensure I get him if I feel he is going to produce similar to a player going much higher.

The Elite

  1. Josh Donaldson, TOR
  2. Anthony Rendon, WAS

The Could Easily Be Elite

  1. Nolan Arenado, COL
  2. Todd Frazier, CIN

Potential Elite with Risk

  1. Adrian Beltre, TEX
  2. Evan Longoria, TB

The Comfortable #1’s

  1. David Wright, NYM
  2. Ryan Zimmerman, WAS
  3. Carlos Santana, CLE
  4. Kyle Seager, SEA
  5. Chris Davis, BAL
  6. Manny Machado, BAL
  7. Kris Bryant, CHC

Power deficient CI’s

  1. Matt Carpenter, STL
  2. Josh Harrison, PIT

Late Round CI options

  1. Chase Headley, NYY
  2. Pedro Alvarez, PIT
  3. Marcus Semien, OAK (2B and potentially SS)
  4. Aramis Ramirez, MIL
  5. Trevor Plouffe, MIN
  6. Xander Bogaerts (SS)
  7. Pablo Sandoval, BOS

Solid Production with Upside

  1. Martin Prado, MIA
  2. Nick Castellanos, DET
  3. Luis Valbuena, HOU
  4. David Freese, LAA
  5. Brett Lawrie, OAK
  6. Alex Rodriguez, NYY
  7. Lonnie Chisenhall, CLE
  8. Mike Moustakas, KC

Deep League Solid Options with Limited Upside

  1. Chris Johnson, ATL
  2. Yangervis Solarte, SD
  3. Mike Aviles, CLE
  4. Casey McGehee, SF

Decent Upside with Playing Time Issues in 2015

  1. Cody Asche, PHI
  2. Maikel Franco, PHI
  3. Miguel Sano, MIN

Sheer Desperation

  1. Brock Holt, BOS
  2. Alexi Amarista, SD
  3. Juan Uribe, LAD

As always please shoot me any questions either on twitter @FPL_brolfe or in the comments section below.

// ]]>

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *