Putting together roto SP rankings and tiers is really tough because at a certain point as with the whole of roto it becomes about balance and with pitching that is a really tough balance to strike. In certain situations you might be able to sacrifice the chase for WHIP in return for catching up some strikeouts and vice-versa.
There is also the difficulty of judging wins. You cannot really chase wins on draft day because so much is down to luck. You can maximize your possibility of getting wins by drafting good pitchers on good teams but sometimes even that isn’t enough and therefore you are better off balancing the other categories and letting wins look after itself to some extent. When fantasy baseball finally switches to a majority of leagues using quality starts then ranking this position will get a lot easier.
Right now I haven’t put too much weight into those guys who remain free agents because there are always starting pitching jobs available and I expect most of the top end guys to be signed in plenty of time. If we get closer to the season and people still aren’t signed then you might see them start to slip down rankings as the risk of missing time gets larger. Saying that though I have only actually ranked two current free agents; Jake Arrieta and Yu Darvish. That isn’t to say others won’t move up if a desirable situation arises but as it stands they are the only two to break into the top 60.
Fake Pigskin Exclusive: Join Monkey Knife Fight and Get an Instant 100% Deposit Match PLUS a Free $5 Game!
As with outfield I have only ranked the top 60 because I envisage at this time in the year most people are setting keepers or just starting slow email draft and therefore there isn’t the need to go any deeper. Here are my top 60 roto SP rankings based on ESPN eligibility.